While Tiffany & Co. is famous for its iconic blue boxes, their "buyback" policy for used jewelry is essentially non-existent.
Instead, the luxury jeweler operates through two very specific programs: a strict 30-day return window and a diamond upgrade program for engagement rings.
Personalized, altered, or engraved items cannot be returned or exchanged.
For most jewelry items, including their popular sterling silver collections, you can only receive a refund if you are within the initial purchase window.
For purchases over $75,000 , no refunds are issued; they are eligible for exchange only. 2. The Diamond Engagement Ring Upgrade Program
Jewelry must be in "perfect saleable condition" with the original sales receipt and all packaging (boxes and pouches).
This is the only "trade-in" option Tiffany offers, and it is limited strictly to diamond engagement rings. What is the Tiffany & Co. Return/Exchange Policy?