The episode begins in St. Louis, Missouri, where a young boy named Andy Tabb vanishes from his bedroom. His parents report receiving a terrifying, silent phone call just before his disappearance. The BAU (Behavioral Analysis Unit) is called in and quickly realizes the case bears a striking resemblance to a cold case from 1985 in Newark, New Jersey, involving a boy named Richard Higgins.
The team discovers that the 1985 case resulted in the father, Malcolm Taffert, being wrongly accused of his son's murder because the body was never found and the "caller" aspect was dismissed as a prank. This adds a layer of tragedy as Malcolm's life was ruined by the UnSub's actions decades prior. [S9E10] The Caller
The BAU tracks the UnSub to a remote area. They find that he has been keeping "trophies" of his victims and that his motivation stems from his own childhood trauma and a distorted need to "save" children from what he perceives as inadequate parenting. The episode begins in St
Fans often rank "The Caller" as one of the saddest episodes of Criminal Minds due to the realistic horror of a child being taken from their home and the long-term devastation it causes families. You can watch the full episode on Paramount+ or other streaming platforms. The BAU (Behavioral Analysis Unit) is called in
While Andy Tabb is rescued, the episode ends on a bittersweet and haunting note. The team realizes that the UnSub had been operating for much longer than they thought, and the sheer number of victims is staggering. Character Dynamics & Development
Hotch remains the stoic anchor, especially when dealing with the grieving parents who are being torn apart by the UnSub's mind games. Critical Reception