After going way too far the previous year and traumatizing the neighborhood children (and Phil), Claire is strictly ordered to keep her Halloween "kid-friendly".
Cam's desperate attempts to find a costume that shows off his new slim physique, only to end up in a bulky father-daughter costume with Lily. [S4E5] Open House of Horrors
Claire goes full Paranormal Activity . Enlisting the kids, she rigs the open house with flickering lights, static TVs, and moving objects, successfully scaring the living daylights out of Phil. 2. The Tucker-Pritchetts: The "Princess" White Lie After going way too far the previous year
Phil's line back to Claire about her scaring people: "You literally scared a little saliva and a little urine out of a man." Enlisting the kids, she rigs the open house
Originally airing on October 24, 2012, this episode perfectly blends the show's signature quick-witted chaos with genuinely sweet, developing family milestones.