The episode's plot, centered on friends being hunted by a past secret involving a car accident, draws strong parallels to the movie I Know What You Did Last Summer , which also starred Jennifer Love Hewitt.
: While Grace and her boyfriend managed to live with the secret, the guilt eventually overwhelmed Lucas. When he attempted to go to the police to confess, the other two stopped him.
As Melinda investigates, she uncovers a dark secret shared by Grace, Lucas, and another friend. Ten years prior, the group was involved in a that killed a motorcyclist. Fearing the consequences, they chose to cover up the death rather than reporting it to the police. Key Conflict and Resolution