: For many viewers, the high point is Brook’s dramatic entrance and his use of the "Three-Verse Humming: Arrow Notch Slash" to defeat the massive spider-monkey, Tararan. This reveal establishes him as a skilled "Humming Swordsman," moving him beyond just a source of "Yo-ho-ho" gags.

: The episode is praised for its blend of spooky atmosphere and "weird and wacky" adventure, which defines the Thriller Bark experience.

: The stakes rise as Gecko Moria reveals his plan to use Luffy’s shadow to create a powerful pawn in his quest to become Pirate King. Critical Reception