Reviewers note that while the signature "twist endings" are present, they can sometimes feel "telegraphed" or dated to modern audiences.

It is widely praised for its incredible roster of talent, including an introduction by John Steinbeck and appearances by Marilyn Monroe (in a very brief, early role), Charles Laughton , and Richard Widmark .

It is often recommended as a "comfortable" or "Sunday afternoon" movie, particularly for those who enjoy old-school sentimentality and irony. Breakdown of the Five Segments O. Henry's Full House (1952)