Some readers find the "graphic-designer speak" (e.g., "rhythmic spatial interconnection") to be pretentious or overly complex for simple concepts. Additionally, older editions contain website case studies that have not aged well. Who is it for?
Timothy Samara’s Making and Breaking the Grid is widely considered a foundational "workshop" for designers, structured on the philosophy that you must master rules before you can effectively subvert them. Reviewers generally praise it as an essential visual reference, though some find the academic writing style dense. Making and Breaking the Grid: A Graphic Design ...
Covers the history and construction of traditional systems, including manuscript, column, modular, and hierarchical grids. It explains how these structures provide clarity and efficiency. Some readers find the "graphic-designer speak" (e
Explores deconstruction and alternative "architectures," such as spontaneous composition, organic methods, and non-orthogonal structures. Reviewer Highlights Timothy Samara’s Making and Breaking the Grid is
Unlike many "lookbooks," it provides the rationale and process behind top designers' work, helping readers understand the why of a layout rather than just the how .
The most frequently cited "pro" is the sheer volume of high-quality illustrations, diagrams, and real-world case studies. It is often described as a "must-have" for a designer’s library specifically for these pictorials.