Reviews of the film are mixed, highlighting both its traditional charm and its adherence to genre tropes.
: While Brendan Penny is a fan favorite, some reviewers felt there was "no chemistry whatsoever" between the leads. Conversely, other fans described the movie as "just beautiful" and a lovely reminder of a "magical time".
: Some praised the "original plot" involving the ornaments, though others noted that the "magical" element felt slightly inconsistent with the otherwise reality-rooted story.
: The story takes a turn when Marie is tasked with editing a book by the ex-boyfriend who caused her original heartbreak, leading her to push Nate away.
